Most Comfortable Shoes for Hammer Toes that Can Alleviate Your Pain

Hammertoe is a condition that makes it difficult or even painful to walk.

The cause of this is the middle joint of the second or third toe bending in an abnormal way.

It gets its name from the shape of the toe once this occurs.

It is most common for this condition to affect the toe next to the big toe, though the third toe may suffer as well.

Wearing shoes with a high heel or narrow toe box long term has the potential to cause this condition.

Check out a pair if you are in a hurry: Men | Women

An astonishing 200,000 people feel the pain of hammertoe in a year. Treatment sometimes requires treatment by a medical professional but is usually self-diagnosable.

The affected toe is often painful to bend and it is likely to develop calluses. Depending on the severity, surgery may be necessary to solve the problem.

Before you result to drastic measures like surgery, however, you should first try buying the right shoes.

Read on to learn about some of the best shoes for hammer toes, so you know what to look for when you go to the shoe store.

For Women

Easy Spirit Women's Romy Sneaker$$4.9 out of 5
Pedors Womens Classic Black Neoprene$$4.8 out of 5
Saucony Women's Grid Omni Walker$$4.7 out of 5

Easy Spirit Women’s Romy

Instead of your hammertoe meeting resistance in these Easy Spirit shoes, they meet nothing but padded comfort.

The inside features a cushioned foam sock liner and a flexible sole.

This design provides less resistance and more comfort as you walk. The heel area is about half an inch higher than the toe box, allowing a natural movement but not being so steep that you worsen your foot condition.

Some other great features of this shoe include a thick rubber sole that absorbs impact so you do not feel the pain, a roomy toe box so you do not worsen your condition, and a padded collar, so you don’t have to worry about blisters while you are breaking them in.

Additionally, these shoes have self-tightening laces that securely hold your shoe to your foot without adjustment. This means you do not have to bend over and risk injury as you put your shoe on.

These shoes are an excellent choice for working or daily activities. In addition to being comfortable, their leather construction allows them to be durable. Some people have even worn these shoes for 5+ years with no change in the level of comfort offered.

Even though these shoes are light weight, you should note that they are not appropriate for high-impact activities like running or jogging.

Additionally, the roomy toe box makes this a little too large for some people so you may want to consider ordering half a size smaller.

Verdict: For low-impact activities like walking or working, these shoes are lightweight, comfortable, and will reduce the pain. 

Pedors Women’s Classic Neoprene

This orthopedic shoe features a construction of all synthetic materials, from the upper to the sole.

It has a thick platform sole that is about 1-inch tall, perfect for providing the impact absorption and support that you need.

The Pedoprene upper stretches in all directions, meaning that it can accommodate severe hammertoe, bunions, edema, and other foot conditions comfortably.

In addition to their comfort, these Neoprene shoes are easy to put on. They feature a touch-closure strap that allows you to adjust them to your comfort level easily, even if your needs change throughout the day.

Some other features include lightweight construction that will not weight your feet down and a removable insole that lets you accommodate custom orthotics if you need them. They are available in three widths, including normal, wide, and extra wide.

The other plus side of the shoe is its machine washability. You can throw them in the washer on the cold setting and let them air dry time and time again, without worrying about damaging the shoe.

The only downside of this shoe is its appearance. It is not the most attractive looking shoe, but you may find that it is so comfortable you do not care. Its black color also makes its orthopedic appearance a little less noticeable.

Verdict: Even with this not being the most attractive shoe, it is an excellent choice to deal with the pain, as well as other foot conditions. It is supportive, provides enough room and an optional orthotic insert, and is comfortable to wear. 

Saucony Women’s Grid Omni

This walking shoe features a unique Grid System that with the purpose of providing comfort as you walk.

The thick rubber sole is full of a grid that absorbs impact, limiting damage to hammertoes.

Its design makes it versatile, for work or casual wear. This shoe offers comfort an orthopedic appearance.

In addition to a Grid System, the Grid Omni has several other features that are beneficial for someone suffering from a foot condition. The design of the outsole allows it to roll forward as you walk, offering a smoother transition from heel to toe that will not aggravate hammertoes.

Additionally, it features a molded EVA insole, HRC cushioning, and a padded sock liner that work to cushion your toes and prevent pain. Finally, the HRC Strobel board adds to the support already provided by the Grid System.

This shoe does offer plenty of cushioning and support, but it is not without its flaws. The sole does squeak, especially on the heel. Fortunately, this issue usually resolves itself in a few weeks.

If you have a wide-set foot, this may not be a good shoe because the toe box can be too narrow. You should always choose a roomy toe box for your foot. Finally, the arch support may be too prominent for some people.

Verdict: This shoe may not be the best choice if you have wide feet, because the toe box may be too narrow. For some people, however, the unique Grid System provides excellent relief for their condition. 

For Men

New Balance Men's MW411 Health$$4.9 out of 5
Orthofeet Ventura Men’s Extra Depth$$$4.8 out of 5
New Balance 624 Men's Training$$4.7 out of 5

New Balance Men’s MW411

These New Balance shoes are black in color, making them a good choice for any occasion.

They work for casual and professional wear. They feature a leather upper with breathable holes. While they are not waterproof, the holes allow your feet to remain cool.

The sole has a thick, synthetic construction with a 1-inch platform that absorbs impact as you walk.

Another benefit of this shoe is that has a roomy toe box and accommodates wide feet. This, paired with the comfortable sole and inner padding, helps relieve pain.

Additionally, this shoes comes with detachable insoles that you can remove to accommodate custom orthotics if you need them.

There are two downsides to this shoe. First, the bottom of the shoe is rather flat. This means it does not roll forward easily and that it may not be great for walking long distances, though it will probably suit your needs for daily activities.

Second, they are not as durable as you may like and the sole tends to separate from the upper. You can fix this specific problem with a little glue.

Verdict: Aside from the lack of durability and the flat shoe bottom, the MW411 is an excellent choice to deal with the pain. They are lightweight, comfortable, and offer the roomy toe box. 

Orthofeet Ventura Men’s Extra Depth

These shoes by Orthofeet feature leather and rubber sole construction and are specifically engineered to help with many foot conditions. The leather on the shoe has sections of stretchy fabric areas that allow breathability and the ability to stretch to accommodate foot conditions.

These shoes are excellent for walking, with an Ergonomic-Stride design created to alleviate stress on the joints of the feet, hips, knees, and back and propel your foot forward.

There are three reasons that these extra depth shoes are beneficial for you. First, they have a multi-layer insole that provides arch support customized to your foot’s needs, as well as gel padding in the heel area to lessen the impact on your foot.

This provides support and comfort, but if you do not like it or you need more room, the orthotic insole is removable.

Second, this shoe features a roomy toe box. Finally, the flexible and deep design of this shoe allows it to accommodate foot conditions without putting pressure on them.

The only downside to this shoe is that your feet may get wet if you walk through the dewy grass, but this is what you sacrifice for the stretchable, breathable upper of the shoe.

Verdict: This shoe is comfortable and relieves the pain while reducing the impact on your joints. It is recommended as one of the best shoes for hammer toes. 

New Balance Men’s MX624V2

This shoe has a leather upper and rubber sole that come together to create a shoe that is very comfortable to walk in, even when you must walk long distances.

There is ABZORB material in the heel and forefoot, working to absorb shock as you walk.

This makes them great for walking long distances, walking around and doing your day-to-day activities, or even sports activities.

As with most New Balance shoes, this is available in wide sizes. They feature thick padding around the inner of the shoe that makes them comfortable.

It also keeps them warm. While the breathable design does cut some of the heat in your shoe, it is not sufficient to keep your feet cool all day long, especially during rigorous activity.

While this shoe has many excellent features, it does have its downsides. The leather upper is very durable, but the upper may separate from the sole as the glue breaks down. This sometimes happens within the first year, though it can be re-glued.

You should also note that these tend to run half a size small and people suffering from hammer toes especially should order a larger size than they normally would because a small shoe means a small toe box and that leads to pain.

Verdict: These shoes are an excellent choice aside from the lack of durability. They effectively deal with pain and make everything from carrying out daily activities to sports possible. 

Read this if it feels like your sock is bunched up under your toes


As you choose the best shoes for hammer toes, you need a sole that will absorb impact, a roomy toe box that will not crunch your toes together, and the right kind of support. For these reasons and many others, the best shoes are:

Best Shoes for Women: Easy Spirit Women’s Romy

In addition to a roomy toe box and plenty of padding, this shoe allows a natural walking movement that will not aggravate your condition. It also features self-tightening laces, which is a nice bonus.

The final reason this shoe ranks among the best is because its durability allows you to wear it for years without a change in comfort.

Best Shoes for Men: Orthofeet Ventura Men’s Extra Depth

These shoes rank as best for many reasons. Their design is especially beneficial for foot conditions and they feature a roomy toe box, many layers of comfort, and a breathable and stretchy design.

The multi-layer insole is another excellent feature because it offers several layers of comfort and shock absorption but is also removable to accommodate a customized orthotic insole.

No hammertoe condition is like another. This means that the only real way to tell if a shoe will alleviate your pain is to try it out and hope for the best. Do your research and buy somewhere with a good return policy so you can find the ideal shoe without hassle.